What Can I Make With What I Have? We Tested Two Recipe Finders
We typed 20 real fridges into Supercook and our finder. One found more meals to cook right now, the other more meals that use up your food.
A recipe finder can show you what you can cook right now with nothing else, or what is worth cooking with your food if you pick up one or two things. Supercook, a free ingredient search site, leans hard toward the first. Our free finder leans toward the second.

We typed the same 20 fridges into both in October 2026 and read every one of the 400 top-ten results. Supercook found far more recipes you can make tonight. Ours found recipes that use more of what you have, and in our test it showed no technique pages, dead links or repeats. Both have misses, listed below.
How we tested
We wrote 20 fridges of 3 to 10 ingredients each, the way people type them, including one typo ("tomatos"). A few of them:
- chicken thighs, rice, broccoli, soy sauce, garlic
- eggs, spinach, feta
- bananas, oats, peanut butter
- shrimp, noodles, bell pepper, ginger, soy sauce, sesame oil
- chicken breast, lemon, garlic, parsley, potatoes
- tuna, mayonnaise, celery
Each list went into each tool as a signed-out visitor on a desktop browser, with no filters. We kept the first 10 results and opened every one to read the recipe's full ingredient list. For Supercook that meant the source recipe page. For ours it meant the recipe page on RecipeClip that the card opens, which is our copy of the source recipe. Both tools were judged on the same assumed staples: salt, black pepper, water, cooking oil, white sugar and all-purpose flour.
Each card was scored like this:
- Can you make it? (60% of the card's score.) Yes if nothing is missing, or if the card names exactly what is missing and that is 3 items or fewer.
- Does it use your food? (40%.) How many of your ingredients the recipe uses, up to 3.
- Zero for a how-to page, a dead link or a repeat of an earlier card.
The scoring rules are ours, and the weights are a judgment call. A scorer that counted only recipes you can cook with nothing else would put Supercook well ahead, as the table shows.
Two more caveats. We built our finder over several rounds against these same 20 fridges, and its ranking uses the same formula as the score. On 5 more fridges that we had not built against, recorded on October 16 with an earlier build of ours, we scored 0.90 to Supercook's 0.64. Supercook's order can also change between visits, and its results here are one snapshot from October 15, 2026. Ours were recorded on October 31.
The results
| Out of 200 top-ten cards | RecipeClip | Supercook |
|---|---|---|
| Nothing missing, cook it now | 24 | 141 |
| Short 1 to 3 items, and the card names them correctly | 132 | 7 |
| How-to pages, dead links and other non-recipes | 0 | 24 |
| The same recipe twice | 0 | 8 |
| Your ingredients used per card, on average (non-recipes count as 0) | 3.2 | 1.9 |
| Cards whose "missing" line was wrong | 31 of 200 | 21 of the 169 that showed one |
| Overall score, 0 to 1 | 0.82 | 0.68 |
Counting only its real recipe cards, Supercook's results used about 2.3 of your ingredients each.
Where Supercook did better
When a fridge holds the makings of an obvious dish, Supercook finds it and says you have everything. For eggs, spinach and feta, its first three results were a spinach and feta baked egg, a baked frittata with spinach and feta, and spinach and feta muffins. All three need nothing else and use all three of your ingredients. For bananas, oats and peanut butter it led with peanut butter and banana oatmeal, then breakfast bars and breakfast cookies, again with nothing missing.
Ours did worse on both. For eggs, spinach and feta it led with an Albanian vegetable pie that needs filo pastry and green onions. For the banana fridge it led with 3-ingredient oatmeal cookies missing chocolate chips. Both cards name what they need, and neither is something you can start right now.
Where Supercook went wrong
- Chicken breast, lemon, garlic, parsley, potatoes. 8 of the top 10 said you had everything when you did not. Five of those recipes need a whole chicken, such as a slow cooker whole chicken and a cast iron roast chicken. Another was a meal kit, and another needed a branded spice rub.
- Shrimp, noodles, bell pepper, ginger, soy sauce, sesame oil. Four of the top five were "How to Clean Shrimp", "How To Thaw Shrimp Quickly", "How to clean Shrimp - Five different methods" and "Buying, Storing and Deveining Shrimp". Nothing in its top 10 used the noodles, or anything on the list besides the shrimp.
- Tuna, mayonnaise, celery. A plain tuna salad came first, then celery juice, "How to Freeze Celery" and celery salt.
- Chicken thighs, rice, broccoli, soy sauce, garlic. The first result was a dead link, and the fourth was "How to Defrost Chicken Thighs in Hot Water". The others used only the chicken thighs and left the rice, broccoli and soy sauce for another night.
Across the 200 cards, 24 were how-to pages, dead links or other pages that are not recipes, and 8 repeated an earlier card.
Where ours went wrong
- Few cards you can cook right now. Only 24 of 200 needed nothing more. Most of ours are short one to three things.
- Some top results are not a meal. For the chicken breast fridge, our first two results were gremolata (a parsley and lemon topping) and skordalia (a potato and garlic dip). Both use three of your ingredients with nothing missing, which is why they ranked first. The chicken kebabs and lemon chicken came fourth and fifth.
- Weak lists bring in filler. For tuna, mayonnaise and celery, the top four included tuna-mayo rice balls and a borlotti bean salad. One card's missing line read "cupps rice", a garbled ingredient name.
- The missing line was wrong on 31 of 200 cards, usually by one item. In 13 of them it left out something we treat as a staple, such as whole black peppercorns counted as pepper or oil for deep frying counted as cooking oil. In the rest it left out a different form of something you typed, such as passata counted as tomato sauce, or named an item the recipe does not need.
- 28 of 200 cards needed 4 or more extra items. The card says so.
How our finder ranks recipes
Recipes come from about 35,000 public recipes collected from food blogs and recipe sites, and every card names the site and opens the full recipe. The order works like this:
- Recipes that need nothing more and use a real share of your list (half of it, and at least 2 items) come first. A meat or fish you typed counts double.
- Next come recipes short 1 or 2 items that still use a real share of your list and do not need a meat or fish you left off it.
- Then recipes you can make now that use less of your list.
- Everything else comes last.
To see only what you can cook right now, set "Short by up to" to 0 after your first search. Matching is literal on purpose. "Chicken thighs" does not stand in for chicken breast, and "milk" does not cover coconut milk. If a dish you expected is missing, one rare ingredient on your list is usually the reason, so try removing it.

That card is the first result for the chicken thighs fridge: chicken adobo, short apple cider vinegar and a bay leaf, using the chicken thighs, soy sauce and garlic.
Get better results from any finder
- Type the main things, the protein and vegetables first. A long list of condiments pulls in recipes built around a condiment.
- Name the cut or the form you have. "Chicken thighs", "canned tuna" and "frozen spinach" find better matches than "chicken", "tuna" and "spinach".
- Read the missing line against your cupboard before you choose. A finder that assumes staples may assume one you are out of. In ours, untick "Assume I have salt, pepper, water, cooking oil, sugar and flour" if that is you.
- When you want dinner now, filter to recipes short by nothing. When you want to use up food before it turns, allow one or two missing items.
Try the finder
Open the free recipe finder, type or paste what you have (up to 12 ingredients, plus the staples), and press "Find recipes". Filter by meal, vegetarian or how many items a recipe may be short by. It is free and needs no account. A card's "Save — free" button keeps the recipe in a free RecipeClip account, which holds up to 50 recipes. The help article explains each part of a card, cooking with what you have covers searching your own saved recipes by ingredient, and what to do with half a can has ideas for the odds and ends a finder leaves behind.
Disclosure: RecipeClip publishes this blog and makes one of the two finders we tested.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Supercook or RecipeClip better for using what I have? For a dish you can start right now with exactly what you have, Supercook found far more in our test: 141 of 200 results against our 24. For recipes that use more of your food and name the one to three things to pick up, ours scored higher, with no how-to pages or repeats in its results.
Why does a recipe say I am missing something I have? It may be a different form of the ingredient, such as fresh tomatoes when you typed tomato sauce. Add the exact form you have as its own ingredient.
Does the finder count salt and oil? No. Salt, pepper, water, cooking oil, sugar and flour are assumed unless you untick the staples box.
Do I need an account? No. Searching and filtering are free without one. An account only matters when you want to save a recipe.

